After the group get's Saywer to the top of the embankment, Ana notices that Cindy is missing and begins calling her name. As the camera pans over the creekbed there is some dialogue and someone says, "What" then another voice say, "... your sister" I believe Bernard was speaking and refering that Cindy is/was Libby's sister.

Could be, I dunno. But I don't think that is what he was referring to. :smile:

good call, i just watched that scene again, and Bernard said "your sister..... i dunno, she was....", and then Libby asked, "did they take her?" and had a frantic look on her face

Oh wow. That is a good call if he said "Your sister"

he definitely said "your sister"

That makes 2 sets of siblings.

Libby and Cindy. Shannon and Boone (stepsiblings count!!)

Boone is dead. Cindy's missing. Shannon is.. we don't know yet. So is something going to happen to Libby?

That makes 2 sets of siblings.

Libby and Cindy. Shannon and Boone (stepsiblings count!!)

Boone is dead. Cindy's missing. Shannon is.. we don't know yet. So is something going to happen to Libby?

What makes you think It's Libbys sister? It was Anna that was ready to run down the hill after her. and Anna was never willing to go after anyone else. besides Cindy looks, skin tone and hair color, like she would be related to libby?

What makes you think It's Libbys sister? It was Anna that was ready to run down the hill after her. and Anna was never willing to go after anyone else. besides Cindy looks, skin tone and hair color, like she would be related to libby?

Well the beginning of this post says Bernard saying to Libby that her sister is missing, a.k.a Cindy. It could be a step or half sibling too. Or sometimes some siblings look nothing like each other!

i don't think so... then why would Bernard say "your sister"? and the way Ana reacted at the end, she seemed to put the disappearance all on Eko... i think Ana is just frustrated about losing all of their people...

i don't think so... then why would Bernard say "your sister"? and the way Ana reacted at the end, she seemed to put the disappearance all on Eko... i think Ana is just frustrated about losing all of their people...

Now I'm lost. Is the OP saying your sister to Ana or Libby?

Well the beginning of this post says Bernard saying to Libby that her sister is missing, a.k.a Cindy. It could be a step or half sibling too. Or sometimes some siblings look nothing like each other!

I can vouch for that. In my family, the 3 sisters are: blonde, brunette, and redhead! Not kiddin'. and we all have different color eyes, too.

I have a friend who had four children with the same father. She is white; her husband is Latino. Her eldest has dark skin, black hair, and brown eyes. The second eldest is slightly paler, with dark brown hair and eyes. The third son has pale skin, sandy blond hair and brown eyes. The youngest, who is female, has pale skin, white-blond hair, and clear blue eyes. The older two look Latino, the younger two look white. They all have similar features, though, so you definitely tell that they are related.

Perhaps Libby's sister was one of the original 23 and disappeared just in the way Cindy disappeared--Bernard could have been referring to that. Cindy has an Australian accent, so she and Libby would have been raised apart if they are siblings.

Cardie

Perhaps Libby's sister was one of the original 23 and disappeared just in the way Cindy disappeared--Bernard could have been referring to that. Cindy has an Australian accent, so she and Libby would have been raised apart if they are siblings.

Cardie

I didn't notice an accent on Cindy. She was the same flight attendant that gave Jack his alky correct??

Well the beginning of this post says Bernard saying to Libby that her sister is missing, a.k.a Cindy. It could be a step or half sibling too. Or sometimes some siblings look nothing like each other!

Ok go back and watch the scene again. Ana is the first to notice cindy is gone. When benard says "your sister" Ana is already yelling "Cindy, Cindy!, where is Cindy!" Also Bernard is off screen, so you can not tell who he says it to. The next shot is a shot of libby, and she does look concered. But again Ana is quite freaked by her disapperance. This is not Libbys sister or there wwould have been more than one shot of her reacting. the editing clearly focuses on Ana. Therefore, cindy is Ana's sister. at least that is my story, and I'm sticking with it.

edit---------

with one caveat, Ana does give up rather quickly at the end when she says to Ecko, This one is on you" or your falt or something like that. OK now I'm reconsidering my position.

Ok go back and watch the scene again. Ana is the first to notice cindy is gone. When benard says "your sister" Ana is already yelling "Cindy, Cindy!, where is Cindy!" Also Bernard is off screen, the next shot is a shot of libby, and she does look concered. But again Ana is quite freaked by her disapperance. This is not Libbys sister or there wwould have been more than one shot of her reacting. the editing clearly focuses on Ana. Therefore, cindy is Ana's sister. at least that is my story, and I'm sticking with it.

Hmm okay. Then Ana or Libby with Cindy make another pair of siblings.

Cindy and Libby being related via marriage makes sense. They're step sisters, a parallel to Boone and Shannon. Cindy goes missing so next Libby's gonna go.
They were raised apart, one living in Australia, and the other comes to visit her, perhaps since one of them is the hostess(?) she would be spending time with her in LA when they land.

Cindy and Libby being related via marriage makes sense. They're step sisters, a parallel to Boone and Shannon. Cindy goes missing so next Libby's gonna go.
They were raised apart, one living in Australia, and the other comes to visit her, perhaps since one of them is the hostess(?) she would be spending time with her in LA when they land.

Cindy living in Australia is another parallel to Boone and Shannon, since Shannon was living there as well.

I really need to pay attention to accents! I stink at them!

OK go back and watch the scene again. Ana is the first to notice Cindy is gone. When Bernard says "your sister" Ana is already yelling "Cindy, Cindy!, where is Cindy!" Also Bernard is off screen, so you can not tell who he says it to. The next shot is a shot of Libby, and she does look concerned. But again Ana is quite freaked by her disappearance. This is not Libby's sister or there would have been more than one shot of her reacting. the editing clearly focuses on Ana. Therefore, Cindy is Ana's sister. at least that is my story, and I'm sticking with it.

edit---------

with one caveat, Ana does give up rather quickly at the end when she says to Eco, This one is on you" or your fault or something like that. OK now I'm reconsidering my position.

I think yo are definitely on to something Dr. Kollossus. There was something strange about how Ana blamed Ecko and told him this one is on him. Implying something different than with the other disappearances.

Hi,
This is actually the first time I've posted on this board since I joined it months ago.

I've watched that scene a few times now and a couple times with my closed captioning on and from what I heard and read Bernard actually said "she was just here". There was no reference to a sister. But that's not to say she's not someone's sister, it just wasn't refered to in that scene. Just thought I'd add my two cents.

Cindy and Libby being related via marriage makes sense. They're step sisters, a parallel to Boone and Shannon. Cindy goes missing so next Libby's gonna go.
They were raised apart, one living in Australia, and the other comes to visit her, perhaps since one of them is the hostess(?) she would be spending time with her in LA when they land.

Oooh... this would also fit into the theory that was going around last season about none of the survivors buying their own ticket/not supposed to be on that flight. If Libby and Cindy are sisters, Libby could've been flying for free because of Cindy's job as a flight attendant.

Ana is mad at Eko for taking them into the jungle with the inherent risks... and then a member goes missing. One of her group, not the Lostaways. Maybe under the bitchiness is a mother figure protecting her group. If she's in the armed forces or a cop or something like it, that would fit too - serving to protect.

I didn't hear the "sister" reference but Ana certainly looked very concerned when Cindy went missing. And we just saw Cindy moments before in the shot of Libby handing up the walking sticks and then getting pulled up by Eko.

I wonder if we'll find out where Cindy is, although the promo said "lost forever."

piscescat, I think it's fairly obvious that the someone being "lost forever" was Shannon...(you know, the main character that was killed off last night after 3 weeks of anticipation).

right before bernard says "she was just here" , you hear him say your sister(its not in the close captioning)

I also thought Bernard said "she was just here"
Neither Libby or Ana seem distressed enough to be realted to Cindy - Ana just gives up, and aside from asking "Did they take her?" Libby doesn't seem personally affected.

Maybe Cindy had a sister on the flight with her that wasn't Ana or Libby. I seem to remember reading way back that some of the flight attendants were twins. Maybe Cindy had a twin on the flight and when Bernard says sister, he's refering to Cindy's sister that went missing during "the other 48 days". I'm just guessing though because I didn't pick up on Bernard saying sister the first time around. I guess I know what I'm doing tonight - HAHA. (like I wasn't planning on rewatching this episode 100 times again anyhow)

Well, Baybee, the promos like to misdirect, you know. What about all that fuss over a death looking like it'd be Locke and then it turned out to be the science teacher? They like to make you think it's one thing and then it's another. Of course it's obvious Shannon is going to die, but she's not lost. She's in Sayid's arms. Cindy is missing.

Hi,
This is actually the first time I've posted on this board since I joined it months ago.

I've watched that scene a few times now and a couple times with my closed captioning on and from what I heard and read Bernard actually said "she was just here". There was no reference to a sister. But that's not to say she's not someone's sister, it just wasn't refered to in that scene. Just thought I'd add my two cents.

Welcome islandgirl, and you have finally become brave to post. I'm the same way. I love reading the posters views and finally joined this forum after watching lost since the first day. So, I'll probably be on the tarmac for a while.

Yes, in closed caption he says"she was just here".............................

I think he says "she was just there" not "your sister".

Hi Fancyface,

Cute screen name btw. And thanks for the welcome. I've been a member for over a year now and only posted for the first time last night. I guess I was just biding my time.

Hi Pedro,

Yeah, I watched that ep. one more time before erasing it and watched that scene three more times. Only thing I heard just after Ana-Lucia said "Cindy?" the first time was one of the guys say "ok, ok, here" as they were putting Sawyer down. Then Ana says "Cindy? Where's Cindy?" and then Bernard says "she was just here". I hear no reference to a sister either.