Welcome to the watching live thread!!! Please try to keep the posts topicy and have something more to say besides "Look at what Kate did!!!!" or "OMG!!!".

Enjoy!!!

Is it just me or have there been an abnormally large number of commercial breaks in this episode?

commercials make me insane! So Christian and Sarah? .. and Zeke=gay?

darn it must be crazy on here tonight. nice of fake henry gale to shut the door on Juliet. He is very tender.

lmao @ it only took the bears 2 hours!

"Heyy! You got yourself a fish biscut."

Priceless.

"Heyy! You got yourself a fish biscut."
I loved that line, but I equally loved his retort, "How many bears?" lol

Seriously, the psychological aspect of this episode is just crazy.

So Penny's actually Juliet on the island. Are we talking clones? Or is it a different person?

Was the other guy a plant or what?
I mean the lostie in me says yes, but my new theory in me says no. Only superficial viewing equals no more crazyness over theories.
100%
when the epi started i said penny, like desmond last season. the eye and music

So Juliet and Penny are different people, they seem to be played by different actresses according to IMDB, they look so alike, the producers are messing with us.

Did anyone see tht it was Zeke that Jack was working on. In my opnion it needed to be two hours!!!:P Besides that I loved it!

So Penny's actually Juliet on the island. Are we talking clones? Or is it a different person?

Elizabeth Mitchell = Juliet. Sonya Walger = Penny.

Relax, we'll see Penny soon enough...

Man, that was a good premire.

Not as good as last year though.

My favorite part was when Sawyer won his "Fish biscut" and his conversation with Mr. Friendly.

Did anyone see tht it was Zeke that Jack was working on. In my opnion it needed to be two hours!!!:P Besides that I loved it!
Really? I didn't see that at all, that's cool.

was the Zeke? I thought he looked familiar... but damn, really?

I need to watch that again...

I know ABC posts the show tomorrow on its website but, does anyone know when exactly? I'm already working on finding a link to download it but, I'm sure that's going to be the quickest way.

Did anyone see tht it was Zeke that Jack was working on. In my opnion it needed to be two hours!!!:P Besides that I loved it!

where do you mean? didn't notice. what scene?

where do you mean? didn't notice. what scene?

I'm assuming he means in the scene where Jack's with a patient and nurse but watching his father answer the phone. I didn't see the guy on the bed but that would be the only scene he was treating someone.

I'm assuming he means in the scene where Jack's with a patient and nurse but watching his father answer the phone. I didn't see the guy on the bed but that would be the only scene he was treating someone.[/quote]

gotcha thanks! reviewing DVR now

BTW....the book they were reading is Stephen Kings CARRIE.



http://www.stephenkingshop.com/images/books/king/covers/carrie/carrie_signet_expo.jpg

I did a slow mo of the shot and my VCR can go slow enough to see when she flips the book over when she is sitting on the couch.

Ok, here's a question. What was up with all of the scene cutting? I know I already mentioned the Sawyer scene but, what about the Jack saving the choking girl scene?

Ok, here's a question. What was up with all of the scene cutting? I know I already mentioned the Sawyer scene but, what about the Jack saving the choking girl scene?


Maybe they left that scene out ... or maybe those pictures were "foilers" put ut by TPTB to keep us guessing.

Maybe they left that scene out ... or maybe those pictures were "foilers" put ut by TPTB to keep us guessing.

I thought that I heard someone choking at the end of that first flashback scene?

commercials make me insane! So Christian and Sarah? .. and Zeke=gay?


No, Zeke is not necessarily "gay" because Kate is not his type. I find certain women more attractive than others and that does not make me "gay." May Zeke likes plus sized women (now you're talking, brother).

No, Zeke is not necessarily "gay" because Kate is not his type. I find certain women more attractive than others and that does not make me "gay." May Zeke likes plus sized women (now you're talking, brother).

I didnt mean to imply he was gay just because he said that, its more from a spoiler that was posted in the spoiler section earlier today about someone in the Kate shower scene being gay.

I missed the last minute of the episode. After Juliette convinced Jack to sit down, what happened?

Would make sense with the comment. That seems to be the new phrase to out a character before actually outting him.