I had the feeling that when John said Cooper pretends to be family--that he was not his real father. I would not be surprised if Cooper told him this in an upcoming epi. It would explain a lot. I know the transplant lend to the idea that he is his father..but a con man could find a compatable donor.

also
The Box seems to be the Smoke Monster

and judging by what the smoke monster can manifest---Cooper may NOT be Real.

If he is real....The Box/monster also *could explain how the plane was sucked toward the island by Bens wish for a spinal surgeon--why a whole plane and not just Jack?.Easy..this is TV. I dont understand why people thinks its an actual box..he only usd the word "Box" because he was just talking about the Box company.

I think it was also clear that Copper is the Man from Tallahassee. This name was given to allude to the idea that They GOT him from Tallahassee. Theories that he was on the plane or came there himself are totally shot down by the Title. So dont even bother with that.

I think Ben is also former Dharma basd on his comments..Jacob also is former Dharma(he was in the Dharma Video)


Great epi..I thought Kate was very powerful

There are no confirmations on wether the smoke monster can actual manifest itself as other beings, this is still all just speculation.

There are no confirmations on wether the smoke monster can actual manifest itself as other beings, this is still all just speculation.


Hey eli

Yes there is. All you have to is watch episodes to see that. But you can check the Podcasts if you want.

woah when was jacob in the dharma video? If you were referrering to Room 23, I would think that is a new Brainwashing video for the others rather than dharma. I would disagree and it was made clear that Ben Linus is not dharma but one of the hostiles that have been living here longer, a lot longer(according to mikhail) In the podcast on 3/20 Darlton confirmed that The others = the hostiles

Jacob also is former Dharma(he was in the Dharma Video)

Please clarify. Which DHARMA video? You don't mean the orientation films? Do you mean the film Karl was being brainwashed with? "Jacob" was mentioned in text during the film, but did we actually see him?

I had the feeling that when John said Cooper pretends to be family--that he was not his real father. I would not be surprised if Cooper told him this in an upcoming epi. It would explain a lot.

What would Cooper saying "I'm not your father" to Locke explain other than just that?

also
The Box seems to be the Smoke Monster

and judging by what the smoke monster can manifest---Cooper may NOT be Real.Cooper is real. You don't ask someone to bring you someone who isn't real. And I don't see why manifestations would be bound and gagged.

If he is real....The Box/monster also *could explain how the plane was sucked toward the island by Bens wish for a spinal surgeon--why a whole plane and not just Jack?.Easy..this is TV.Hilarious explanation. Thank you.

I think Ben is also former Dharma basd on his comments..Jacob also is former Dharma(he was in the Dharma Video)

Based on what comments? And because Jacob's name was in a brainwashing video administered by the Others does not mean that Jacob is/was Dharma.

There are no confirmations on wether the smoke monster can actual manifest itself as other beings, this is still all just speculation.
I think it is made to be pretty obvious. If you're expecting the writers to connect the dots more fully than what they've alredy done, I have a feeling you're going to be disappointed.


I think Ben is also former Dharma basd on his comments..Jacob also is former Dharma(he was in the Dharma Video)
Funny, I've felt that all the most recent evidence has indicated the exact opposite-- that Ben and his crew have been around long before Dharma.

What would Cooper saying "I'm not your father" to Locke explain other than just that?
I think the poster meant it might explain how Cooper could not only betray his "son's" trust, but also attempt his own murder. I tend to disagree with this, though; during their relationship I get the distinct impression that Cooper didn't treat Locke like "just another con."

I think the poster meant it might explain how Cooper could not only betray his "son's" trust, but also attempt his own murder

That makes zero sense as something that Cooper not being Locke's father would explain.

I think it is made to be pretty obvious. If you're expecting the writers to connect the dots more fully than what they've alredy done, I have a feeling you're going to be disappointed.

These aren't any dots that explain manifestation in any science or psuedo-science terms. I have a feeling that you are ascribing attributes to some dots that do not exist.