Did anyone else notice that the theory that when Desmond went back in time, he caused Rose and Bernard to not crash on the island has been debunked? Rose was at the plane crash.

I was looking for her and missed it.

what's this theory?

I didn't see her either. Do you have a screen cap? It would be great to settle this once and for all.

Boone wouldn't be asking for a pen had not Rose still been there.

I saw Jack giving her CPR in the background, and that's also why Boone was looking for a pen, remember?

And sorry, no screen caps. I don't know how to do that.

Tachyon,
The theory is that when Desmond went back, he changed events so that Rose and Bernard were replaced with Nikki and Paulo.
100%
Boone wouldn't be asking for a pen had not Rose still been there.

That's right. I forgot the pen was for Rose. Never mind! ;)

Here's a screencap (http://img407.imageshack.us/img407/6193/rosefm1.jpg)

I think it's Boone trying to give her CPR before Jack shows up and tells him he's doing it wrong.

How do you do that?

I saw ROSE im so happy

Did anyone else notice that the theory that when Desmond went back in time, he caused Rose and Bernard to not crash on the island has been debunked? Rose was at the plane crash.

What kind of theory was that in the first place???Going back and caused Rose and Bernard not to crash???to explain the reason why we dont see much of them lately'???i dont think so!kind of sci fi ,far fetched and surreal:cool:

What kind of theory was that in the first place???Going back and caused Rose and Bernard not to crash???to explain the reason why we dont see much of them lately'??? i dont think so! kind of sci fi , far fetched and surreal:cool:

It is the kind of theory that has been circulating around this site for quite some time.
You might not like it much but others have taken it to heart.
We will see if it pans out.

It is the kind of theory that has been circulating around this site for quite some time.
You might not like it much but others have taken it to heart.
We will see if it pans out.
keeping in mind what TPTB ve confirmed otherwise and took time to tell us so,i really think its not safe to leave the safe trail and wonder around,scheming surreal stuff!i mean,we already know that these two actors (Rose and Bernie)have a heck of a lot other stuff to do,hence their island disappearance.im sorry if i sound hostile and rude,its not my intention.i respect all theories whatsoever,but i just panic at the 54546654654645 ways we could be lead off track.and we really tend to do so.

What did they confirm?
That Rose and Bernard are till with us?
That the time line has not changed.
That all the odd little references to time are just production errors?
Other than the pic of Rose, I see nothing else, as proof positive, that this could not be true.
If they have confirmed this or any of the above in a pod cast please, a link would be great.
Keep in mind that they also like to misdirect.

What did they confirm?
That Rose and Bernard are till with us?
That the time line has not changed.
That all the odd little references to time are just production errors?
Other than the pic of Rose, I see nothing else, as proof positive, that this could not be true.
If they have confirmed this or any of the above in a pod cast please, a link would be great.
Keep in mind that they also like to misdirect.

yes ,of course,i do keep in mind that they often play tricks with us,but i dont think they can fool us brilliancies!:cool:i m just referring to their confirmation that Renards disappearance has to do with the actors' busy schedules.ive been hearing this since season 2,mags and all.im sorry,i dont wanna sound fanon,but i guess its common knowledge.:confused:right?

see I don't read the mags so that would explain or different outlooks on this post :)
It still could be the case. Even if the actor or actress is just busy ;)

see I don't read the mags so that would explain or different outlooks on this post :)
It still could be the case. Even if the actor or actress is just busy ;)

TPTB have confirmed in a recent podcast that theres a Renard episode coming and that well be gruntling with awe!!!whatsmore theyve claimed that they didnt wanna make the actors just show up to shoot a couple of scenes just standing in the background.they both are extraordinarily good actors and Rose husbands real life health problems only add up to her absence from the show.plus,in Expose we saw Boone givin Rose mouth to mouth at the beach in a recycled pilot sequence so ,the theory that Pikki is Renard or whatever is at least debunked! :)

A picture of Rose on the island is enough confirmation for me.

A picture of Rose on the island is enough confirmation for me.


ok ,here s your proof!that's Rose in Expose receiving CPR from Boone. (http://img75.imageshack.us/img75/7089/vlcsnap1254161xd4.jpg)

TPTB have confirmed in a recent podcast that theres a Renard episode coming and that well be gruntling with awe!!!whatsmore theyve claimed that they didnt wanna make the actors just show up to shoot a couple of scenes just standing in the background.they both are extraordinarily good actors and Rose husbands real life health problems only add up to her absence from the show.plus,in Expose we saw Boone givin Rose mouth to mouth at the beach in a recycled pilot sequence so ,the theory that Pikki is Renard or whatever is at least debunked! :)

Link please?
I have listened to the last couple pod cast.
How did I miss such a big clue?
I need to go back and listen again.

Link please?
I have listened to the last couple pod cast.
How did I miss such a big clue?
I need to go back and listen again.
You can find the statement in the 3-30-07 podcast ,the one with Eddie Kitsis.
its definite..Renard is there!!!!Pikki is NOT Renard!!!!! YIPPIE KI YAY


the podcast can be found here (http://ll.media.abc.com/podcast/audio/itunes/Lostpodcast_20070330.mp3)

ok ,here s your proof!that's Rose in Expose receiving CPR from Boone. (http://img75.imageshack.us/img75/7089/vlcsnap1254161xd4.jpg)

I think you misunderstood me. I was saying that it's already obvious that she's still on the island, because we've already seen a picture of her on the island. In fact, I started this thread.

I think you misunderstood me. I was saying that it's already obvious that she's still on the island, because we've already seen a picture of her on the island.

oh,im sorry!i thought you asked for a clue!anyways,it can be used as proof for other doubters!its TPTB confirmed that Renard is there,though:)

It's fine, I should have been more clear. I was being too sarcastic.

You can find the statement in the 3-30-07 podcast ,the one with Eddie Kitsis.
its definite..Renard is there!!!!Pikki is NOT Renard!!!!! YIPPIE KI YAY


the podcast can be found here (http://ll.media.abc.com/podcast/audio/itunes/Lostpodcast_20070330.mp3)

Thanks! I had missed that one

Thanks! I had missed that one
No worries brutha!im only happy well be seeing em again and about the expose (sic)of the whole surreal Renard disappearance theory.as for now,im off to watch Die Hard .:cool:

And because some fans apparently STILL cling to this crazy theory, Gregg Nations officially cleared it up for good:

http://www.thefuselage.com/Threaded/showthread.php?t=74342

Finally gald to see its all cleared, not that I believed it though.

I know, they couldn't possibly even think of replacing Rose and Bernard with.... Nikki and Paulo.

Plus, Rose and Bernard are supposed to be in the next two episodes. Including the season finale... O.o That's when all the bad stuff happens, though...