Although it was inadvertent, he buried Nikki alive and can now join the rest of the Losties on the island who have killed someone. I guess if he had to accidentally kill someone the best person would be Nikki. Go Hurley!

Although it was inadvertent, he buried Nikki alive and can now join the rest of the Losties on the island who have killed someone. I guess if he had to accidentally kill someone the best person would be Nikki. Go Hurley!

So, now that Hurley indirectly killed Nikki, that means that everyone on the island had killed someone ,or cause someone death , directly,or indirectly. Sun killed Colleen, Micheal ,killed Ana and Libby. I would not be surprise if Rose, or Bernard kill someone next.

what makes you think they're dead? I'm expecting the zombie-like shot of the hand coming out of the ground one of these days!

hurley already indirectly killed the people on the dock that collapsed


but right now u can say every lostie had a hand in burying them, so they have all now been responsible for someone's death. and that, combined with locke killing that russian dude means every single character has either murdered someone or is presently dead.


to me that is huge.

what makes you think they're dead? I'm expecting the zombie-like shot of the hand coming out of the ground one of these days!

Well, the producers (Damon & Carlton) do like to joke about season 7 being the "zombie season" :biggrin:

Remember when the balcony collapsed and people died, that is when Hurley had to go the the loony bin. If you are counting this as killing someone you have to count that.

Have Claire or Walt (currently MIA) killed anyone?
Jin?

Has Claire killed anyone? What about Jin? He beat a lot of people up...

We don't know what happened to Claire's Mother, so we don't have an answer for that. Walt killed that poor bird..flap, flap, flap, smash! :eek2: and Jin was in a rather violent profession, but there is no evidence that they killed anyone. I don't think that you can count this or the balcony accident as killing someone. An accident is not the same as intentionally taking someone's life.

Did Sun kill anybody???

Sun killed an other on the boat.

We don't know what happened to Claire's Mother, so we don't have an answer for that. Walt killed that poor bird..flap, flap, flap, smash! and Jin was in a rather violent profession, but there is no evidence that they killed anyone. I don't think that you can count this or the balcony accident as killing someone. An accident is not the same as intentionally taking someone's life.

Did Sun kill anybody???

Sun shot and killed Colleen, who was Danny Pickett's wife. ( one of the others) so far it seem like just about everyone on the island is directly, or indirectly responsible for someone else's death.

Boone cause the death of his nanny/maid indirectly. Boone cause her to fail down the stairs.

Locke indirectly cause the death of Boone, and his father's step son to be. ( Locke indirectly cause his father's step son to be 's death, by telling his father that he was investigating him. Locke also killed Patchy.

Sayid cause his friends death.

Michael killed Ana ,and Libby

Claire was driving the car that put her mother in a coma ( since Claire's mother is still alive, it doesn't count. Yet. she might have indirectly cause Scott's death, to no fault of her own.

Kate -kill her father Wayne
Sawyer- killed the guy he thought was Sawyer

Hurley indirectly cause the death of two people .

Charlie -killed Ethan
Eko- kill a lot of people
Ana- kill a guy who made her lose her child.Killed Goodwin
Juliett- killed Danny
Ethan- might have killed Charlie.suspected of killing Scott/steve
Goodwin- killed Nathan
Desmond- Killed Kelvin
Paulo- killed Nikki's movie director lover.
Nikki -killed Paulo



People we are not quite sure about:

Walt- could he be responsible for his mother sudden illness?
Jin- could he had kill someone, or cause someone death in the past?
Rose and Bernard- could they be hiding something?
Jack- Everyone has a secret. Could Jack be hiding something.

People we are not quite sure about:

Walt- could he be responsible for his mother sudden illness?
Jin- could he had kill someone, or cause someone death in the past?
Rose and Bernard- could they be hiding something?
Jack- Everyone has a secret. Could Jack be hiding something.


I guess my point would be that for taking part in the funeral/burial of Nikki and Paulo, all the present people are indirectly responsible for their deaths. That would include Jin and Rose/Bernard (they weren't show but they are supposed to be there the whole time as background characters)...This means that all LOSTIES, including faceless/characterless ones have now caused someone's death.

So you're right the only ones not confirmed to have murdered are

Walt - someone that was taken and then claimed to have been 'more than they bargained for'

and

Jack - seeming to be recruited into Other society.


I still think this is significant.

Didn't Jack kill the marshall? Mercy killing, but still.

Nikki and Paulo are not dead, remember what Locke said and they woke up plus they where not dug in very deep, they will break out of there easy. Trust me.

Didn't Jack kill the marshall? Mercy killing, but still.
Wasn't Sawyer the one to kill the marshall?

hey folks,

there is a vast difference between

killing (per se)
murder
attempted murder
manslaughter
premeditated murder
self-defense

the list goes on.

honestly, if everyone who had a hand
in someone's else's death went before a judge,

the judge would throw out most of the cases.

circumstances count a lot.

in hurley's case, he did not kill or murder anyone.

in a court of law, it would be deemed
an accidental death at the hands of
the deceased.

you could stretch it out and maybe... maybe
charge hurley with negligence for not
checking (again) the vitals of nikki and paulo.

but that's a stretch because sawyer and
some others were there also and they
did not have any reasonable doubt that they
were indeed still dead.

nikki created a chain of events that lead
to her and paulo being buried alive.

it looks like nikki caused her own death
and paulo's.

as far as everyone else like sun,
i would argue self-defense.

in fact, i could find a defense for everyone
on the island. of course it depends on
how much they are willing to pay.

no kidding.


remember, "the absent are always wrong."

p.s. this message officially got me "off the tarmac."
okay, i'm in "baggage" but at least on the plane.
i can live with that... for now.

why is everyone saying Nikki n Paolo are dead? i mean, people are talking as if they were shot at point blank range in the head, and not bitten by spiders that make u appear that deceased.....

and why did Nikki wake up 1st when Paolo was bitten 1st? My guess is that when all those males arrived, their combined bites killed Paolo since they slow your heartrate down to a crawl and his was already crawlin....

they arent dead until we know they are....i doubt both of them are

Go Hurley and Sawyer! Sawyer has already killed four people on the island:

The marshal - shot him in the chest. I know, Jack finished him, but Sawyer shooting him would have killed him soon enough
An Other - Sawyer shot an Other in the season finale
Nikki and Paulo!

Awesome!

all our losties seem to have killed someone in their pre island lives.Sun somewhat enforced Jae Lee to his plunge,Hurley had the platform accident ,Claire had driven her mom into a coma and so on and so forth..everyone knows what its like to do something bad to someone.premeditated or accidental.