Well, at least she's getting better. No more outright lying to Jin, eh? :rolleyes:

Actually in this case, I think a lot people would have a hard time telling their loved one that some relative stranger told them they would die because they are living on an island where pregnant woman do not survive.. It's a really strange thing to communicate when you think about it.

Your right Pen. It would've been disconcerting to see Jin's heartfelt smile wither away instantly.

I think it's the right thing to do, for Sun not to tell Jin everything that Juliet told her. What could he do about it anyway. Only worry, and Sun is worrying enough for all of them.

It must be so hard for Jin not to understand everything that is said. I'm worried that he is one of the ones left to fight. He better not get killed off!!!

She was right not to tell him yet. Especially not right before a dangerous confrontation. That might make him do something stupid!

Well, at least she's getting better. No more outright lying to Jin, eh? :rolleyes:
Hey, at this rate, she might be upfront and honest by season five!! :rolleyes:

Hmmm...I don't agree. He's her husband. It's his child. He deserves to know the peril that she's in, even if he can't do anything about it. She can use his support. Besides, everyone else in the camp knows, and someone is going to bring it up with Jin sooner or later, expecting that he is fully aware. Then there's another crisis in the Kwon tent.
Sun should stop hiding things from him even if she thinks it's for his own good.

I actually thought it was a sweet scene, mostly because there was some part of her that was truley happy that she could tell him it was "their baby". It least that's how I saw it.

I thought everyone was staring at Jin because of the "he was sterile before he came to the island" comment. Which Sun still didn't tell him about, but people are less likely to bring up.

Hmmm...I don't agree. He's her husband. It's his child. He deserves to know the peril that she's in, even if he can't do anything about it. She can use his support. Besides, everyone else in the camp knows, and someone is going to bring it up with Jin sooner or later, expecting that he is fully aware. Then there's another crisis in the Kwon tent.
Sun should stop hiding things from him even if she thinks it's for his own good.
I absolutely agree with you!
I don't understand why she doesn't tell him about it. Maybe that's one more cultural difference?

I thought everyone was staring at Jin because of the "he was sterile before he came to the island" comment. Which Sun still didn't tell him about, but people are less likely to bring up.
That's true. It's a strange thing to hear even if you've been on a very strange island for three months!