Now we know why they called him Charlie, In all dogs go to heaven Charlie the dog knowingy dies drowning to save a girl, and he knows he will die because he has a pocketwatch that counts down the moments left in his life (just like when desmond tells charlie how long he has)

Right.....
Just like when Locke got shot then came back to save the day, much like John Wayne. That must be why Lockes first name is John.

Since they had that scene planned 3-4 years ago when they named the characters, I bet you're right!

Seriously?

that was what we like to call a joke, a funny coincidence and kind of laughing at how every grabs at any little thing to make grand theories.
you guys really thougt that was serious?

You know a joke is a joke because you laugh. That joke simply wasn't funny.

You have to understand sarcasm, Im sorry if it went over your head, I will stick to jokes off bazoola joe from now on

Since they had that scene planned 3-4 years ago when they named the characters, I bet you're right!

Seriously?

They didn't know they'd do that scene when the show started. They only just recently decided to kill Charlie.

Woah, calm down guys. It was a bit of sarcasm.