The scenes with Charlotte tonight made me wonder if she is possible another daughter of Christian? Or possibly Ben and Annie's daughter?

The scenes with Charlotte tonight made me wonder if she is possible another daughter of Christian? Or possibly Ben and Annie's daughter?

I think that would be an overkill, they don't need to do that storyline twice.

I find it more plausible that Charlotte is Annie, or the daughter of Annie. Because Annie had red hair didn't she? I know it far-fetched but just wondering. :)

Charlotte wouldn't be the right age to be Annie.

If she was Annie why would Ben shoot her?

Annie had brown hair and brown eyes, I'm pretty sure. And if anyone we know is Ben and Annie's daughter, my guess is it's Kate.

I think Charlotte could be a Widmore. Maybe Widomores once lived on the island.

I think Charlotte could be a Widmore. Maybe Widomores once lived on the island.

That could be possible. Charlotte has now become very interesting.

I got the impression Charlotte was born on the Island, did she state that or infer it?
She was there before, I wonder how she was there and how she left? interesting!

I got the impression Charlotte was born on the Island, did she state that or infer it?
She was there before, I wonder how she was there and how she left? interesting!
She made a comment about looking for her birthplace, which I'm assuming would be the island, especially since Miles said she was there before.

I want to know more about her now!

Since red hair is such a tough gene to pass on, I am thinking at least one of her parents would have to be a noticeable redhead. The only one I can think of on this show is Emily, Locke's mother!

When you think about it, it makes sense. Emily was pretty unstable (mentally) later on - sorta like Jack and Hurley are now. And didn't Locke have a sister who "died" - or was that his foster sister????

:cool:

Since red hair is such a tough gene to pass on, I am thinking at least one of her parents would have to be a noticeable redhead. The only one I can think of on this show is Emily, Locke's mother!

When you think about it, it makes sense. Emily was pretty unstable (mentally) later on - sorta like Jack and Hurley are now. And didn't Locke have a sister who "died" - or was that his foster sister????

:cool:

That is one hell of an age gap if it turns out to be Locke's sister!

That is one hell of an age gap if it turns out to be Locke's sister!
With time travel, age gaps don't mean a whole lot.

I think Charlotte is Annie and Ben's daughter.